What are First Principles?
As a software engineer, I’m always challenged to break down problems and tasks according to first principles. This means identifying the most foundational truths and working my way upwards. At work, it’s not about first selecting a language or framework, but asking what problem I am trying to solve. If my application is too slow, first principle thinking asks what aspect is slow and what result am I trying to achieve. Or, to bring it out of the technical realm, we may want our teenager to spend less time in front of screens. The knee-jerk reaction is to ban devices. But the first principle thinking asks what he is trying to do or accomplish on devices. Are there other ways to scratch that itch?
After the recent mid-term elections in the United States, I think it’s time for many Catholics to get back to first principles. What do we ultimately want out of our government and elected leaders? What are these people actually saying and endorsing? And most importantly, as Catholics, who will allow me to best pursue fostering my relationship with God?
What the Church Teaches about Voting
It’s not complicated. The Catholic Church provides guidance on how we should approach politics. Not all issues are of equal weight. The Church teaches us that we must vote and support candidates that best fit these non-negociable, foundational principles:
- Preserve the dignity of human life
- Uphold the sanctity of marriage between one man and one woman
- Preserve religious liberty so we can worship God always and everywhere
Breaking down voting to first principles parallels what is taught in scripture. Despite the hundreds of rules that Israelites lived by, Jesus stated that they all come from this one, foundational rule — Love God with your whole heart. All the other rules whether that be how to dress, what to eat, and how to pray, come from that one rule. Those regulations must follow that single law to be valid. In fact, much of the debate in Jesus’ time came from scholars asking whether a given law actually follows that first principle. For example, how does not laboring on the Sabbath relate to loving God with our whole heart?
When we live according to first principles, the decisions we need to make become a lot easier. This includes the decisions we make socially and politically. If we don’t follow the Church’s teachings, we aren’t living our Catholic faith. This includes our political actions. Living our faith isn’t something that is optional and we can cast aside when we feel like it. In fact, that is exactly what sin is — disobeying the life that God calls us to. Jesus told us that following him won’t be easy. It wasn’t easy for the early Christians nor is it easy for modern day Catholics.
The Counter Arguments
Someone always points out, “but don’t these principles basically tell us to vote conservative?” And it does seem like a bit of curve fitting that the Catholic Church’s principles align more with conservative political thought than liberal. But these principles weren’t invented by George Bush and Donald Trump. These principles predate any political party or modern country. Any elected official has the choice to decide which principles he/she will stand for. It just happens to be that conventional conservative thought happens to align better with Catholic teaching.
If I tried to get into all the various counter arguments, I would be writing a book, not an article. But one thing that often comes up is that conservative parties, particularly Republicans, have their faults too. So why can I ignore the deficiencies of one candidate and not the other? It’s because not all strengths and deficiencies carry the same weight. It’s impossible for our laws to reflect our ultimate desire for God’s mercy and grace when they don’t start from first principles. And we need to be honest — many of the people we are electing and laws we are passing aren’t starting from those moral and ethical foundations. When the Israelites turned away from God’s commandments, terrible things happened to them. It’s a warning to us that when we don’t live or vote according to God’s will, terrible things will happen to us as well.
Turning to Prayer
I don’t want to be all doom and gloom. The snarky side of me would say that all of this is just expediting the collapse of civilization and our return to our home in God’s kingdom. But snark aside, let’s remember that all this anxiety over the fate of our country provides more of an opportunity to turn towards God in prayer. All too often, God uses times of anxiety and turmoil as a “wake up” call to our slumbering spirit. In prayer, we should be asking for God’s help to realize and live by His foundational truths.

This is a good time to return to daily prayer, particularly the Rosary. We should be reading scripture as well as other spiritual books. Now is a good time to practice fasting and sacrifice. We should be reverently receiving the sacraments, particularly Reconciliation and the Eucharist. When we do this, we open our hearts and our minds to God. It may not be easy to live according to his will in a world that seems to have no intention of following him. But God will grant fortitude, wisdom, and knowledge to anyone who sincerely desires to live for him.
